I got the turtleneck in charcoal as my favourite navy was not available. Being only 5'3'', the sleeves were a way too long for me and at first I wanted to shorten them. However, over the really cold weather I was happy to have the extra length for warmth. Will however still shorten them a bit as they can get in the way for better 3 season wearability. The turtleneck itself was a bit wide for me and tends to fall down a bit, but still provides the extra coverage around the neck I was looking for. Seams are holding up, no pilling so far. I went with the size indicated by the sizing chart but probably would go one size down the next time with the experience of how it wears. The material is very soft, stretchy and lovely to live in, in addition to all the other merino advantages. Thinking about getting another one in a different colour. Would love to try another type of garment over time.